Hermann Ackermann, Wolfram Ziegler
Audra Ames, Sara Wielandt, Dianne Cameron, Stan Kuczaj
David Ardell, Noelle Anderson, Bodo Winter
Rie Asano, Edward Ruoyang Shi
Mark Atkinson, Kenny Smith, Simon Kirby
Andreas Baumann, Christina Prömer, Kamil Kazmierski, Nikolaus Ritt
Christian Bentz
Aleksandrs Berdicevskis, Hanne Eckhoff
Richard A. Blythe, Alistair H. Jones, Jessica Renton
Cedric Boeckx, Constantina Theofanopoulou, Antonio Benítez-Burraco
Megan Broadway, Jamie Klaus, Billie Serafin, Heidi Lyn
Jon W. Carr, Kenny Smith, Hannah Cornish, Simon Kirby
Federica Cavicchio, Livnat Leemor, Simone Shamay-Tsoory, Wendy Sandler
Zanna Clay, Jahmaira Archbold, Klaus Zuberbuhler
Katie Collier, Andrew N. Radford, Balthasar Bickel, Marta B. Manser, Simon W. Townsend
Jennifer Culbertson, Simon Kirby, Marieke Schouwstra
Christine Cuskley, Vittorio Loreto
Christine Cuskley, Bernardo Monechi, Pietro Gravino, Vittorio Loreto
Dan Dediu, Scott Moisik
Sabrina Engesser, Amanda R. Ridley, Simon W. Townsend
Dankmar Enke, Roland Mühlenbernd, Igor Yanovich
Kerem Eryilmaz, Hannah Little, Bart de Boer
Nicolas Fay, Shane Rogers
Maryia Fedzechkina, Becky Chu, T. Florian Jaeger, John Trueswell
Olga Feher, Kenny Smith, Elizabeth Wonnacott, Nikolaus Ritt
Piera Filippi, Sebastian Ocklenburg, Daniel Liu Bowling, Larissa Heege, Albert Newen, Onur Güntürkün, Bart de Boer
Piera Filippi, Jenna V. Congdon, John Hoang, Daniel Liu Bowling, Stephan Reber, Andrius Pašukonis, Marisa Hoeschele, Sebastian Ocklenburg, Bart de Boer, Christopher B. Sturdy, Albert Newen, Onur GÜntÜrkÜn
Molly Flaherty, Katelyn Stangl, Susan Goldin-Meadow
Marlen Fröhlich, Paul H Kuchenbuch, Gudrun Müller, Barbara Fruth, Takeshi Furuichi, Roman M Wittig, Simone Pika
Victor Gay, Daniel Hicks, Estefania Santacreu-Vasut
Andreea Geambasu, Michelle J. Spierings, Carel ten Cate, Clara C. Levelt
Matt Hall, Russell Richie, Marie Coppola
Stefan Hartmann, Peeter Tinits, Jonas Nölle, Thomas Hartmann, Michael Pleyer
Wolfram Hinzen, Joana Rosselló
Rick Janssen, Bodo Winter, Dan Dediu, Scott Moisik, Sean Roberts
Rick Janssen, Dan Dediu, Scott Moisik
Jasmeen Kanwal, Kenny Smith, Jennifer Culbertson, Simon Kirby
Deborah Kerr, Kenny Smith
Buddhamas Kriengwatana, Paola Escudero, Anne Kerkhoven, Carel ten Cate
Adriano Lameira, Jeremy Kendal, Marco Gamba
Molly Lewis, Michael C. Frank
Casey Lister, Tiarn Burtenshaw, Nicolas Fay, Bradley Walker, Jeneva Ohan
Hannah Little, Kerem Eryılmaz, Bart de Boer
Hannah Little, Kerem Eryılmaz, Bart de Boer
Giuseppe Longobardi, Armin Buch, Andrea Ceolin, Aaron Ecay, Cristina Guardiano, Monica Irimia, Dimitris Michelioudakis, Nina Radkevich, Gerhard Jaeger
Heidi Lyn, Stephanie Jett, Megan Broadway, Mystera Samuelson
Michael Mcloughlin, Luca Lamoni, Ellen Garland, Simon Ingram, Alexis Kirke, Michael Noad, Luke Rendell, Eduardo Miranda
Adrien Meguerditchian, Damien Marie, Konstantina Margiotoudi, Scott A. Love, Alice Bertello, Romain Lacoste, Muriel Roth, Bruno Nazarian, Jean-Luc Anton, Olivier Coulon
Jérôme Michaud
Ashley Micklos
Marie Montant, Johannes Ziegler, Benny Briesemeister, Tila Brink, Bruno Wicker, Aurélie Ponz, Mireille Bonnard, Arthur Jacobs, Mario Braun
Yasamin Motamedi, Marieke Schouwstra, Kenny Smith, Simon Kirby
Roland Mühlenbernd, Johannes Wahle
Tomoya Nakai, Kazuo Okanoya
Savithry Namboodiripad, Daniel Lenzen, Ryan Lepic, Tessa Verhoef
Alan Nielsen, Dieuwke Hupkes, Simon Kirby, Kenny Smith
Bill Noble, Raquel Fernández
Irene M. Pepperberg, Katia Zilber-Izhar, Scott Smith
Lynn Perry, Marcus Perlman, Gary Lupyan, Bodo Winter, Dominic Massaro
Ljiljana Progovac
Andrea Ravignani, Tania Delgado, Simon Kirby
Terry Regier, Alexandra Carstensen, Charles Kemp
Lilia Rissman, Laura Horton, Molly Flaherty, Marie Coppola, Annie Senghas, Diane Brentari, Susan Goldin-Meadow
Gareth Roberts, Mariya Fedzechkina
Carmen Saldana, Simon Kirby, Kenny Smith
Carlos Santana
William Schueller, Pierre-Yves Oudeyer
Catriona Silvey, Christos Christodoulopoulos
Katie Slocombe, Stuart Watson, Anne Schel, Claudia Wilke, Emma Wallace, Leveda Cheng, Victoria West, Simon Townsend
Ruth Sonnweber, Andrea Ravignani
Michelle Spierings, Carel ten Cate
Kevin Stadler, Elyse Jamieson, Kenny Smith, Simon Kirby
Monica Tamariz, Joleana Shurley
Monica Tamariz, Jon W. Carr
Bill Thompson, Heikki Rasilo
Oksana Tkachman, Carla L. Hudson Kam
Simon Townsend, Andrew Russell, Sabrina Engesser
Francesca Tria, Vittorio Loreto, Vito Servedio, S. Mufwene Salikoko
Anu Vastenius, Jordan Zlatev, Joost Van de Weijer
Tessa Verhoef, Carol Padden, Simon Kirby
Slawomir Wacewicz, Przemyslaw Zywiczynski, Arkadiusz Jasinski
Bodo Winter, David Ardell
Bodo Winter, Lynn Perry, Marcus Perlman, Gary Lupyan
Marieke Woensdregt, Kenny Smith, Chris Cummins, Simon Kirby
Eva Zehentner, Andreas Baumann, Nikolaus Ritt, Christina Prömer
Keywords: Ostensive acts, Gricean Communication, pointing comprehension, apes, dogs, gesture
Short description: Dogs and bonobos use ostensive cues to follow human gestures, potentially clarifying part of the evolutionary path to language.
Abstract:
One recent argument concerning the evolution of language centers on the ability of the last common ancestor of apes and humans to engage in Gricean communication (that is, communication in which the speaker has the clear intent to produce a response, but also with the intent that the hearer can recognize the communicative intent of the speaker (e.g. Moore, 2015; Scott-Phillips, 2015; Tomasello, 2008). The standard argument (see Moore, 2015) has been that true Gricean communication requires fourth-order meta-representation (the speaker intends for the hearer to understand that the speaker intends for the hearer to understand the message) and is therefore unique to humans. In this conception, animal communication is limited to strict associations (coded communication) and Gricean or ostensive communication was the key innovation in the evolution of language.
An alternative view suggests that the representation required for ostensive communication is much simpler (see Moore, 2015 for an explanation) – the speaker intends to communicate a message to the hearer and the speaker also intends for that message to represent something in the world (two first-order meta-representations). On the receiving end, then, the hearer must both understand that the speaker is intending to communicate (through overt or covert intentional cues) and must decipher the message (the signal). The intent to communicate would itself be communicated through an ostensive act or cue – an act designed to draw attention to and facilitate the receipt of a communicative signal. Ostensive cues can include eye contact and shifting of joint attention, among other behaviors. These ostensive cues remain separate from the communicative signal, which could include gestures, verbalizations, etc. Under the standard view, nonhuman animals should rely entirely on associative learning to follow a signal such as pointing. In this scenario, nonhumans should perform at the same level when a communicator uses ostensive cues as when those cues are eliminated.
To evaluate this theory, we tested 3 bonobos (Pan paniscus) from the Ape Cognition and Conservation Initiative (ACCI) in Des Moines, IA on the object choice task (point following) both with and without ostensive cues (in this case, ostensive cues included gaze alteration between the gesture and the recipient). When ostensive cues were removed, the apes’ performance fell from almost perfect to chance levels, indicating that ostensive cues are vital for the performance of bonobos in this task (p<.01, binomial tests).
A new study has been initiated with domestic dogs (Canis familiaris) at the Humane Society of South Mississippi in Gulfport, MS. A total of forty dogs will be tested on a variety of ostensive cues to determine which if any are most salient. To date, twenty-five dogs have begun testing, but only twelve passed the initial evaluation of following eye gaze. Of those twelve, eight could follow a distal point, but only two could follow a cross-body point (required for our study). In this stage, the ostensive cues tested were gaze alterations among the three points of the joint attention triad – gesture and recipient, gesture and referent, and recipient and referent. Neither dog could follow points with all ostensive cues removed, although one had no difficulty when alteration to any one point of the triad was eliminated (e.g. eye gaze only moved between gesture and recipient, but not to the referent).
These findings strongly indicate that nonhuman animals utilize overt ostensive cues to recognize gestural communication from humans, suggesting that the development of ostensive cues was not the key innovation that triggered the evolution of human language. Rather, the dog data reinforce the likely crucial social component of gesture comprehension in nonhumans, as the dogs in this study almost certainly had less human interaction and performed less well than pet dogs in other studies, again indicating more than strict associative learning.
Citation:
Lyn H., Jett S., Broadway M. and Samuelson M. (2016). Nonhuman Animals’ Use Of Ostensive Cues In An Object Choice Task. In S.G. Roberts, C. Cuskley, L. McCrohon, L. Barceló-Coblijn, O. Fehér & T. Verhoef (eds.) The Evolution of Language: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference (EVOLANG11). Available online: http://evolang.org/neworleans/papers/173.html